Stop Avoiding Resistance: What to Do When Coaching Receives Pushback

Shannon Streett headshot

Shannon Streett,

Chief of Staff & Development

October 22, 2026

To address teacher resistance to instructional coaching, start by clarifying the purpose of coaching, identifying what’s behind the pushback, and matching your response to the teacher’s needs. The "Diagnose → Act → Forget → Go Back" framework helps instructional coaches navigate difficult conversations, build trust, and keep coaching focused on improving instruction and student learning.

Edu20/20 Insights graphic for “Stop Avoiding Resistance: What to Do When Coaching Receives Pushback,” by Shannon Streett, October 21, 2026, featuring educators participating in a professional learning activity.
The Reality of Pushback

One of our team members tells a story about when she first started teaching. Her brand-new coach popped her head into a classroom where teachers were planning together and said, “Hi, everyone! Just here to let you know that I didn’t drink the district Kool-Aid yet, I’m still one of you! I’m just here to support and we are all a team. I will start individual coaching soon, but no stress.”

Can you imagine the teachers’ reactions? If they didn’t already know what instructional coaching was about, they were just programmed to be on high alert. And if they did, well, the door was just opened for them to invite familiar pushback in.

“My kids can’t do that.”
“We tried that already.”
“I’ve been teaching for 16 years. Why do I have to change?”

This type of resistance is not new, but it is real and it gets very uncomfortable, very fast. When it rears its head, it’s easy to default to avoiding the teacher, backing off, or staying frustrated while biting your tongue and trying to focus on those who are willing to be coached. But if we stay in default mode, coaching stalls and students lose. Instead, we need a reframe to understand it.


Resistance is a sign that coaching is touching on something real. In her book How to Coach Teachers to Teach (Almost) Anything, Jill Jackson gives us the best advice:

EVERY SINGLE COACHING PRACTICE is met with resistance. If it’s not met with some push back along the way, I would guess that the coach isn’t asking anyone to change anything. (p. 105)

As instructional leaders, we have to treat pushback as information, not failure. And, more importantly, we need a simple framework to manage it instead of reacting (or, not acting at all). We learned this simple yet powerful strategy from Jill. She taught us to diagnose what is potentially at the root of resistance, act to work through the resistance with the teacher, forget how they acted, and go back to coach again in the next cycle:

Four-step process diagram showing a cycle from “Diagnose” to “Act,” then “Forget,” and finally “Go Back,” connected by dotted arrows.


Diagnose: Check Yourself First

Here’s a hard truth. Before we ever label a teacher as resistant, we have to ask ourselves if we ever gave them anything to say “yes” to. And by yes, we mean laying a collaborative groundwork for coaching: the purpose or the “why.” Without a “why,” coaching feels like, “Am I in trouble?” “Who’s checking on me?” or “What did I do wrong?” Remember the brand-new coach from our opening story? She meant well, but instead of sharing why coaching existed and what everyone was working toward, she distanced herself from the purpose altogether. Her teachers had nothing to say yes to.

The leadership team has to check themselves first. The principal must set the “why” of coaching by communicating a collective instructional goal and how coaching will be used to reach it. The instructional coach has to keep the “why” alive, reinforcing it in every coaching cycle and driving improvement toward that goal. 

This foundation is critical. Without a purpose, resistance is a reasonable response. The fix is communication. If you can’t answer these in one sentence each, start here.

  1. Our school’s instructional goal is…
  2. Coaching exists here because…
  3. Coaching will look like…

If you need to bring even more clarity to your coaching launch conversations or see a few examples, use this free resource as a springboard: Coaching Launch Conversations: Example Scripts.

Diagnose: What’s Underneath the Pushback

Once you’ve checked yourself and you find that resistance is still there, it’s time to look at the underlying cause. It is really important here to consider data or facts from the teacher’s conversation, not how the conversation made you feel. Here are a few examples:

Common Resistance Possible Underlying Causes
They embrace defeatism The teacher feels it’s safer not to try anything than to try something and fail or look foolish. (Because it’s HARD!)
They lack confidence The teacher is scared she doesn’t have what it takes to reach the principal’s instructional goal.
They fear failure The teacher doesn’t want to be seen as weak or less than professional as she gets her self-worth from being valuable to others.
They have a negative history The teacher truly has been burned and is afraid to trust the coach (or herself!) out of fear it will happen again.


Once you identify a possible underlying cause, it’s much easier to choose a path forward when it’s time to act. But a note of caution– sometimes what looks like resistance is actually indifference. If the teacher’s response leans more toward indifference, treat it as an opening and begin coaching. Trust is built through the process over time, especially when teachers can see the improvement in their own instructional data. 


Act: Match Your Approach to the Cause

This step is where the instructional leader moves from being reactive to being responsive by choosing an intentional approach. Let’s consider some possible moves that match the underlying cause of resistance shown previously.

IF… THEN…
They embrace defeatism Model something very simple for the teacher with her students and have the teacher collect specific data during your model. (Ex: number of students who responded to a question) Then debrief the results together so she sees success is possible. 
They lack confidence Choose a skill the teacher is close to mastering, and go for a quick win.
They fear failure Break off a tiny chunk of content at a time, and keep the teacher focused on that ONE THING instead of the big picture.
They have a negative history Ask the teacher to pinpoint where coaching went south and what the trigger point was so that you can avoid it.

 

These are just a few examples of some actions you can take, but sometimes that may not be enough. Sometimes….(insert big dramatic pause)…it’s more about OUR skill level in conversations than about the teacher’s actual response.

So what do we do?

Let’s be real– who actively goes out and seeks hard conversations? (Not us, looking away quickly!)  But managing hard conversations requires real skills at different levels to make a real impact.  Are you able to:

Level 1: Regulate YOURSELF (your body reactions, your mind) when pushback appears
Level 2: Hold Space (for the teacher who is trying to communicate something real) without running away
Level 3: Defuse or take away the argument
Level 4: Redirect and Lead to move conversations forward and get back to coaching

If you’d like to know more about these levels or get a jumpstart on improving your conversational skill set, start here → Responding to Resistance: Conversation Skills.


Forget How They Initially Acted

Don’t carry feelings from the last pushback conversation into the next one. Jill Jackson said it best:

Resistance to coaching doesn’t have to be tricky. It should be anticipated and managed. And as you’re managing it, you shouldn’t use resistance as the marker of whether your coaching is successful or not. (p. 105)


Go Back and Keep Coaching

In her book, Jill borrows a line from Dan Rockwell that we keep central to our work: ‘The point of resistance is where the fruit appears.’ And it’s so true. Our job as instructional leaders is to create and hold a vision for student learning, and we only get different results when we take different actions. The status quo doesn’t serve any of us in moving effective instruction forward. It takes action and consistency. Forget past feelings and keep going back. There is one big caveat that we have to acknowledge. What do we do when the pushback is downright rude and borderline unprofessional? Keep going back, and if it continues after three tries, it may be time to tag in the principal. Here’s how Jill handles it in her book:

I go back three times and act like they’re not resistant.

Three times.

On the rarest occasion…I will talk with the principal and say something like, ‘You know, I am not confident I can coach [name] successfully. Would you be willing to coach her for a while until she’s a bit more ready for me? (p. 109)


The Investment of Coaching

Coaching is an investment that requires a return, not just activity. But resistance isn’t the marker of whether coaching is working. We stop avoiding resistance by diagnosing it, acting on it, forgetting how it felt, and going back, all while sharpening our conversation skills. If you’d like one more tool to think through the Diagnose→Act→Forget→Go Back framework, here’s a list of self-questions to get you exactly where you need to go: Stop Avoiding Resistance Resource. 

Every coach meets resistance. The ones who grow are the ones who keep going back with a plan. If you’re ready to build that plan, explore the Edu20/20 Instructional Coaching Institute.

Beyond the Checklist: Making Walkthroughs Work For You

Shannon Streett headshot

Shannon Streett,

Chief of Staff u0026 Development

October 6, 2026

Every box is checked. So what changed for teachers or students?rnrnIf you’re a principal or an instructional coach, you know this checklist. Walkthroughs land on the calendar because the district requires them. Every classroom gets a visit, the data gets turned in, and the box gets checked. But a checked box doesn’t tell you what to do next, and it doesn’t help a single teacher grow.

Beyond the Checklist: Making Walkthroughs Work for You. Every Box Is Checked. So What Changed? By Shannon Streett, October 6, 2026. Includes the author’s portrait and a classroom observation form.

Watch the webinar

✓ Curriculum implementation walkthroughs = done.
✓ Every teacher’s been seen =  done.
✓ Data turned in to the district = done.

Every box is checked. So what changed for teachers or students?

If you’re a principal or an instructional coach, you know this checklist. Walkthroughs land on the calendar because the district requires them. Every classroom gets a visit, the data gets turned in, and the box gets checked. But a checked box doesn’t tell you what to do next, and it doesn’t help a single teacher grow.

Think back to when you were in the classroom. When someone walked in with a clipboard, how did you feel?

Scroll through teacher social media and you’ll see how many teachers feel today: anxious, frustrated, and sometimes even angry about walkthroughs. That frustration is valid, and it’s giving us real-time information that is worth listening to.

Leader tension is real, too. Leaders have to be in classrooms, and without a clear plan, the urgent stuff wins every time. Scheduled walkthroughs fix that by putting classrooms on the calendar. But a walkthrough on the calendar isn’t the same as a walkthrough with a purpose. When walkthroughs happen just for compliance, they break trust.

I’ve been on both sides of the walkthrough clipboard. As a teacher, I knew the drill: the notice, the knot in my stomach, two or three observers in the back of my room, scribbling notes. Then they left, and I never heard another word. No feedback. No next step. Looking back, those walkthroughs checked every box. But nothing changed for me or my students, because no one ever came back to tell me what they saw, what to try next, or how it would shape the support we got.


 

Going beyond the checklist means creating walkthroughs that actually work for you. And a walkthrough only works for leaders when it also works for teachers. Let’s go through the lifespan of a walkthrough: the ground zero issue that starts it all, three red flags we see over and over, and the green flag moves that fix each one.

The Life of a Walkthrough: Where walkthroughs get stuck on the checklist. Four stages and their pitfalls: 0, Why—The Compliance Checklist; 1, Before—The Communication Gap; 2, Right After—A Weak Feedback Plan; 3, The Long Game—The Data Dumpster.


 

Ground Zero: The Compliance Checklist

Before we get to the red flags, we have to start at the root. Most walkthrough problems grow out of one thing: walkthroughs that happen because the district said so.

They get thrown on the schedule. Every classroom gets visited. Or the coach goes around alone while the principal isn’t really involved. Either way, the walkthrough becomes the goal instead of a tool, and it’s missing a purpose.

Let’s be clear about one thing: we’re not talking about your walkthrough tool or form. The tool isn’t the problem. The compliance mindset is. The checklist we’re talking about is the compliance checklist: every teacher seen, box checked, done.

If leaders aren’t crystal clear on why they’re doing walkthroughs, teachers won’t be either. And that’s where trust begins to break down.

Green Flag Move: Know Your Purpose

Know your “why” before it ever hits the calendar. Start by answering the most important question:

Why are we doing these walkthroughs, and what are we going to do with what we see?

If you can’t clearly and confidently answer that question, don’t proceed with those walkthroughs yet. That’s the first step beyond the checklist.
Once you know your why, the next step is making sure your teachers know it too.


 

Red Flag #1: The Communication Gap

What It Looks Like: Teachers don’t know when you’re coming, what you’re looking for, or what happens with what you see. So they fill in the blanks themselves, and they usually fill them with worry. (Or they do what my teaching partners and I did: create a code for the group chat. THE EAGLE HAS LANDED, everyone.)

Green Flag Move: Communicate

Give a window, not a surprise. You don’t have to name the exact day and time. Something as simple as “Our team will be visiting classrooms next week” goes a long way.

We hear the pushback: “If I tell them, I’ll get a dog and pony show.” You can still give a window without naming the exact day. Walking into a room full of anxiety, with a teacher who feels completely unprepared, doesn’t do anybody any good.

Name the look-fors. Tell teachers what you’re coming to see. Maybe it’s curriculum implementation. Maybe it’s a recent lesson planning expectation, like posting objectives or success criteria. Maybe you’re looking for instructional trends to decide next steps for collaboration or coaching support.

Tell them how the data will be used. Say what it’s for: coaching cycles, teacher collaboration, and professional development decisions. Then say what it’s not for. Every teacher is quietly wondering, “Is this going in my file?” Answer that question before they have to ask it.

Need a starting point? Our Example Communication Email shows all three moves in action. Read it and look for the window, the look-fors, and how the data will be used. Then tailor it to your own walkthrough focus.

Communication sets the promise. The feedback conversation is where you keep it.


 

Red Flag #2: A Weak Feedback Plan

What It Looks Like: Walkthrough feedback shows up as a generic form email, a face-to-face conversation that comes weeks too late, or nothing at all. The connection between coaching and instructional improvement is built on trust and face-to-face relationships. A form email doesn’t build either.

The pushback we hear most: “I don’t have time to have a conversation with every single teacher.” Fair. But we’re not talking about a full coaching conversation.

Green Flag Move: Have a Feedback Plan

Keep it to 5–10 minutes, face to face. Answer two questions for the teacher:

  • What moves did you make that were positively impacting student learning?
  • What was getting in the way of learning the most, and what is one move that could improve it in the very next lesson?

That’s it. The teacher walks away with one thing they’re doing well and one next step to level up.

Immediate is best. Fast feedback lowers anxiety fastest. If more than one person is doing walkthroughs, try tag-team coverage: one person covers the class while the teacher steps into the hall for a quick conversation. Immediate feedback, no stress.

Pre-schedule the conversations. If immediate isn’t possible, schedule the feedback conversations when you schedule the walkthroughs. Then they don’t get lost when the week gets busy.

Match feedback to the focus you communicated. If you told teachers you’d be looking at curriculum implementation, give feedback on curriculum implementation. You can collect other data for trends, but don’t surprise teachers with it.

So the teacher gets their feedback. Now, what happens to everything you collected?


 

Red Flag #3: The Data Dumpster

What It Looks Like: The data gets collected, but there’s no clear plan for it. Maybe it was collected just to check the box. Maybe plans were made, life happened, and now it’s sitting in a binder nobody opens. Or the coach is so caught up in individual coaching cycles that there’s no bigger vision for the data.

Be honest: where does your walkthrough data live right now?

Green Flag Move: Use Data as a Compass

Let the data show you the need. Walkthrough data should drive three things:

  • Individual coaching cycles
  • Teacher collaboration and planning support
  • Professional development choices

If we’re spending time, energy, and money, it needs to be based on a real need. The data you collected is your compass.

Have a plan for every walkthrough. Decide what happens with the data before you ever collect it. (Notice how that brings us right back to ground zero?)

Take a look at our Example School Trend Report. It shows what’s working and what’s getting in the way for each teacher, school-wide trends, and what it all means for coaching priorities. As you read it, ask yourself: how could this data address individual needs, and how could it shape collaborative planning support?

One important note: the school trend report is NOT shared with teachers. It includes individual classroom observation data and is meant for coaching conversations and planning. Teachers get their feedback through face-to-face conversation.

A checklist ends when the box is checked. A walkthrough that works ends with a plan.


 

Beyond the Checklist: Putting It All Together

Here’s the life of a walkthrough that actually works:

The Life of a Walkthrough: Where walkthroughs get stuck on the checklist. Four stages and their pitfalls: 0, Why—The Compliance Checklist; 1, Before—The Communication Gap; 2, Right After—A Weak Feedback Plan; 3, The Long Game—The Data Dumpster.

  • Why: Know your purpose.
  • Before: Communicate the window, the look-fors, and how the data will be used.
  • Right after: Have a feedback plan: 5–10 minutes, face to face, matched to the focus.
  • The long game: Use data as a compass.

The checklist tells you every teacher’s been seen. Going beyond it tells you what to do next. When walkthroughs work for your teachers, they work for you.

Free Resources to Get You Started

You don’t have to create a complicated plan or start with a blank page. We made these for you to tailor to your own walkthrough focus:

Where This Goes Next

Whether you’re a principal leading walkthroughs or a coach doing baseline walkthroughs, a walkthrough is only as strong as the coaching conversation that follows it. Coaching is an investment that requires a return, not just activity.

If this post gave you the walkthrough jumpstart, our coaching institutes are where you and your coaches build a framework for coaching that keeps momentum and impacts student learning:

  • Instructional Coaching Institute (ICI): for coaches ready to build methodology.
  • District Instructional Coach Training (DICI): for districts training coaches at scale, and principals who want their leadership team and coaches on the same page.
  • Virtual Instructional Coaching Institute (VICI): for coaches who want the Institute experience remotely.

Learn more about our coaching institutes

Tiering Without Tears: A Simple Way to Decide Who Gets Coached on What

Shannon Streett headshot

Shannon Streett,

Chief of Staff u0026 Development

September 11, 2026

Learn how to tier instructional coaching without overcomplicating the process. This guide shows school leaders how to use baseline walkthrough data and one simple diagnostic question to determine whether teachers need coaching on foundational Priority Skills or support tied to the Principal’s Instructional Goal. It also explains how to identify team-wide patterns, use collaborative planning strategically, and reassess coaching needs as teachers grow.

Watch the webinar

Tiering Without Tears:  A Simple Way to Decide Who Gets Coached on What. By Shannon Streett, September 11, 2026. Includes the author’s portrait and a PD participant raising their hand.

When school leaders have very clear instructional goals, every teacher can benefit from coaching toward those goals. But not the same coaching.

One-size-fits-all coaching either wastes time on teachers who are ready to level up or overwhelms teachers who are still building the basics. So how do we decide who gets coached on what? (In addition to all the other things instructional leaders do?)

You don’t need a complicated plan for every teacher. You just need one question, asked consistently: What is getting in the way of learning the most? This question can help you identify one of two pathways to tailor coaching for teachers and can manage the sorting for you.


 

The Tiering Decision Tree
Based on your collected observation data (we recommend 2 baseline walk-through observations), teachers will fall into one of two categories: Priority Skills or the Principal’s Instructional Goal track.

Flowchart for choosing a coaching focus: Ask, “What’s getting in the way of learning the most?” Then, “Is there a gap in a priority skill?” If yes, follow the Priority Skills Track to identify a team-wide pattern. If no, follow the Principal’s Instructional Goal Track to identify a team-wide pattern.


 

What are Priority Skills?
According to coaching expert Jill Jackson, Priority Skills are the foundational skills that all teachers need to provide strong instruction for students: Classroom Management, Behavior Management, Student Engagement, Lesson Planning, and Delivery of a Basic lesson. Often when something is getting in the way of student learning, the gap can be traced back to a missing or weak Priority Skill. Let’s look at a quick example of what that might look like in the classroom:

Classroom Example:
Ms. Ortiz is a 5th grade teacher. Baseline walkthrough data shows that she has strong classroom and behavior management, but students start to disengage about 15 minutes into every lesson.

In this example, Ms. Ortiz fits in the Priority Skills track since the gap can be traced back to the Priority Skill of Student Engagement. Disengagement is what was getting in the way of learning the most. The goal of the Priority Skills track is to level up instruction quickly (and move toward the Principal’s Instructional Goal track), so let’s examine what it could look like if Ms. Ortiz is coached right at her level of need:

Coaching Example:
After a coaching debrief and some collaborative brainstorming, Ms. Ortiz added a turn-and-talk checkpoint at least every 8 minutes, in line with the rule of thumb of never talking more than 7-8 minutes without giving students a chance to process content or move.

Turn and talks are definitely not a magical fix-all for student engagement issues, but this planning move will allow Ms. Ortiz to practice and get comfortable with turning some of the work over to students while freeing her up to check for student understanding. Then, as she’s ready, she can try different engagement strategies to continue improving her instructional delivery.


 

The Principal’s Instructional Goal Track
Teachers who have a really strong foundation in Priority Skills are ready to be coached and supported in moving student data toward targeted goals. (We call them the Principal’s Instructional Goal, some call them school improvement goals. You get the idea!) Since these teachers don’t have one shared answer the way baselines give the Priority Skills track, it’s helpful to use three lenses to identify how each teacher specifically needs to be coached:

  • What do baseline walkthroughs show?
  • What does student work show?
  • What are teachers reporting as their biggest pain points?

Another classroom example here can best illustrate what this can look like:

Classroom Example:
Mr. Jordan is a veteran teacher with strong foundational skills, and the Principal’s Instructional goal is improving reading comprehension scores by the spring benchmark. Baselines walk-throughs show that Mr. Jordan is two weeks behind on the pacing guide. Mr. Jordan flags “many students not reading at grade level and not completing outside-of-class assigned reading” as a pain point.

Note that our example here shows two important lenses– data from the baseline walks and Mr. Jordan’s qualitative data, or his reported pain points. So what can differentiated coaching look like for him? Let’s check out one possibility.

Coaching Example:
Mr. Jordan and his instructional coach decide to try balancing the number of teacher read-alouds with opportunities for students to partner or independently read during class. They also look at lessons to identify moments to monitor comprehension during reading.

In these examples, coaching is differentiated for the teacher’s exact skill need while supporting instructional decisions that will help reach the Principal’s Instructional goal.


 

When It’s a Team Pattern
Sometimes the tiering process reveals a pattern bigger than just one teacher. It’s possible that an entire grade level or content team shares the same skill gap in instruction. Lesson planning is a common example. So what then?

This is prime time to use collaborative planning time as a coaching structure instead of or alongside individual coaching cycles. (We call this working smarter, not harder!) Whether this replaces or supplements individual coaching all depends on the coach’s bandwidth. There’s no single right answer. Here’s an illustration:

Team Example:
The coach notices everyone on Mr. Jordan’s ELA team is struggling with the same pacing issue. Rather than running four 1:1 cycles, the coach decides to use collaborative planning to coach the moves. The team meets once per week to identify the most important parts of the text, where the teacher needs to read aloud, and where students should partner or independently read. The team identifies critical moments to monitor comprehension, and they bring student results back to the next meeting to discuss and adjust plans.


 

Tiering Isn’t Permanent
One critical caveat to this tiering process is that it isn’t a one-time sort. Coached skills should be reassessed every coaching cycle, and a teacher’s track should be shifting as they grow. Tiering should be a growth decision, not a permanent label. Most importantly, teachers should be able to see evidence of their own growth as well as the impact on student learning.

Ready to try this with your own roster? Download the free Tiering Decision Tree Coaching Guide. It walks you through the same decision tree, plus a worksheet to sort your teachers in real time. And also grab this Example Decision Tree Coaching Guide to see what a completed tree can look like.

Knowing where to focus is the first step. Our Instructional Coaching Institute helps you turn that focus into coaching that moves instruction forward, from setting goals and planning coaching cycles to leading conversations and tracking progress. Join us in person, learn virtually, or bring the training to your district. Explore our Instructional Coaching Institute to find the option that works for you.

Instructional Coaching Data: How to Identify and Solve School-Wide Problems

Courtney Dumas headshot

Courtney Dumas,

CEO

February 24, 2026

If instructional coaches keep reteaching the same priority skills, that is not a coincidence. It is a system signal. This post explores how to analyze coaching data trends, diagnose root causes, and move from isolated teacher support to school-wide solutions.

The Problem: We Collect Coaching Data but Don’t Analyze the Big Picture

Most schools collect coaching data. Coaches track meetings. They log skills. They run cycles. But almost no one stops long enough to ask one important question: What patterns are showing up?

If your coaches keep working on the same skills with the same teachers, your coaching program is not the problem. Your system is.

What We Noticed: A Cohort Pattern Example

In a recent virtual meeting with a cohort of instructional coaches from multiple districts, our team asked them to step back and analyze one month of their data using just a few reflection prompts. Within ten minutes, every coach saw the same thing.

They were all coaching classroom management. The same skills.  The same teachers.  The same cycles. That was the moment we realized this wasn’t a coaching problem. It was a system problem.

Here are some other patterns that appeared:

  • Coaches were repeatedly working in Priority Skills* 
  • Classroom management was the most frequently coached indicator
  • New skills would be started but weren’t sticking. Many teachers were staying at the same skill level in their cycles.

At first glance, these looked like a lot of individual teacher needs, but when the pattern appeared across multiple schools, it signaled something bigger was going on.

The Deeper Diagnosis: A System Problem, Not a Coaching Problem

In our conversations, we shifted the lens from individuals to systems and began to look at some possible causes behind the data:

  • Lack of school‑wide classroom routines
  • Inconsistent expectations across classrooms
  • Limited principal reinforcement
  • Initiative overload getting in the way of basics

There were other common aspects in the data too important to ignore. Coaches are supporting new teachers who enter the profession from multiple pathways. All teachers are faced with new student behaviors, new curriculum, new initiatives. This means that Priority Skill coaching is vital, but without system support, foundational practices never become “normal.” Coaches end up trying to convince teachers to do things that should already be routine practice. That is a system failure, not a coaching failure.

The Solution: Analyze, Then Act

Here are the most effective steps we have found to identify and address the data needs at a larger scale:

Step 0: Stop and Look

Most coaching data sits in spreadsheets that no one studies. If no one looks for patterns, nothing changes.

Step 1: Analyze coaching data trends

  • What skills are being repeatedly coached?
  • What skills are being coached with little to no transfer?
  • Which teachers are repeating the same coaching cycles?

Step 2: Diagnose system issues

  • What school structures are missing?
  • Where are expectations inconsistent?
  • What structures, if implemented across the school, would improve classroom instruction data?

Step 3: Take school-wide action

  • Define non‑negotiable routines
  • Determine walkthrough expectations
  • Model practices in staff professional development
  • Embed into onboarding for new teachers

What Pattern Analysis Looks Like in Action

Step 0

The leadership team stops and looks at the big picture in the coaching data.

Step 1

70% of teachers in coaching cycles were receiving support for Classroom Management, 

Step 2

Coaching notes showed the same issue again and again. The first 10 minutes of class were chaotic. Students entered slowly. Attendance dragged on. Objectives were unclear. 

Instructional time was being lost.

Step 3

Coaches and principals used collaborative planning time to co-design a school-wide entry routine with teachers. The goal: launch instruction within 6 minutes.

Notice what didn’t happen. Coaches did not start more cycles. They addressed the system. Imagine if they kept coaching classroom management to one teacher at a time.

Why This Matters: Coaching for Impact

Repeating coaching cycles on the basics drains two precious resources: time and energy. Coaching works best when it is not fighting the system. If coaches are stuck teaching the basics over and over, the problem is bigger than coaching. The patterns are already there in the data. Ignore them, and coaching stays stuck. Fix the system, and coaching accelerates.

Student Engagement: A Mirror, Not a Magic Fix

Courtney Dumas headshot

Courtney Dumas,

CEO

October 29, 2025

In my previous blog, I argued that vaguely instructing teachers to ‘increase student engagement’ isn’t helpful feedback. This week, after a few classroom observations, I realized something else: sometimes what we call an engagement problem isn’t just about engagement.

In my previous blog, I argued that vaguely instructing teachers to ‘increase student engagement’ isn’t helpful feedback. This week, after a few classroom observations, I realized something else: sometimes what we call an engagement problem isn’t just about engagement.

Let’s look at an example in which I co-planned student engagement for a middle school ELA lesson. The goal was to get the students doing more of the work. We decided to have students work with partners and give them a task–Partner A would identify one character’s perspective and Partner B would identify a different character’s perspective using sticky notes. Then they would discuss their evidence with each other before completing a T-chart. 

Here’s how that looked in two different classrooms where the teachers planned the exact same engagement strategy for the exact same lesson:

Teacher A

Teacher B

  • Students partner-read the chapter straight through. 
  • 4 out of 28 students were off-task.
  • 7 students didn’t have anything written on their sticky notes.
  • 11 of them had one low-level inference of their character’s perspective written down.
  • The longer time went on, the more restless students became, and some were finished while others were still reading.
  • The teacher read the entire chapter out loud. She walked around the room making sure students were reading or listening.
  • Students were compliant with following along.
  • There was no way to determine if students were on track or not during the duration of the read-aloud. 
  • Students discussed what they wrote at the end of the chapter.

But wait…we added student engagement to our plans. Wasn’t that supposed to magically fix instruction? So why were the results between the two classrooms so different? Both teachers tried something new, and that’s exactly what revealed the deeper issue.

Student engagement has so many layers. It’s not just about being fun and entertaining, or just having students talk. It’s not only about motivating students and having them physically participating. True engagement is the product of teacher moves that keep learning flowing.

Neither teacher did anything wrong! In fact, their efforts revealed that “adding student engagement moves” is not a quick fix. There are other elements that critically factor into student learning. We realized the problem wasn’t engagement itself, but what surrounded it. By adjusting three key layers, everything changed.

True engagement is the product of teacher moves that keep learning flowing.

Lesson Pacing

We chunked the lesson into a little bit of teacher reading, partner reading, and independent reading. This kept the lesson pacing snappy and allowed students to engage with the text in different ways. At the end of each chunk, we gave students a quick minute to jot on their note and then turn and discuss with their partner.

Classroom Management

During partner reading and discussion, we designated which partner was to read and which partner would share first. This eliminated the awkward time lapses when students were trying to determine who was going to read and start talking first.

Clarifying Directions and Modeling

We changed the directions so that each student was collecting at least three lines of text that revealed their characters’ perspectives, and we provided a quick two-minute model. Students were way more engaged in actively writing on their sticky notes than in the first period classes.

The data changes in both classrooms during the second run were phenomenal. By making a few quick tweaks, we had built student confidence, set clear expectations, and managed the engagement so that learning could take place. The real payoff came when we had clear moments throughout the lesson where we could monitor if students were on track.

Takeaway for Teachers

Before planning for student engagement, pause and ask yourself:

  • Lesson Pacing: Have I chunked the lesson so that there is a balance of teacher, partner/group, and individual work time? Where do I need to give students time to process and practice?
  • Classroom Management: Do students know exactly what to do and how to engage? Are there any routines I need to shore up?
  • Modeling: Are directions concise? Where will I need to model thinking expectations?

 

Takeaway for Leaders

Before giving feedback about student engagement, pause and ask yourself:

  • Lesson Pacing: Was the pacing clear and varied?
  • Classroom Management: Did students know exactly what to do and how to engage?
  • Modeling: Were directions concise, and has the teacher modeled the expected thinking?

 

Often, what looks like an engagement problem is really a sign that one or more of these bulleted items needs tightening. In your next walkthrough or coaching conversation, don’t just look for engagement, look through it to see what is being reflected back in the lesson. 

What ‘engagement issues’ have you seen lately that might actually reveal a different instructional need? Let us know in the comments!

Stop Saying “Increase Student Engagement”

Courtney Dumas headshot

Courtney Dumas,

CEO

October 27, 2025

“Let’s all work to increase student engagement so that students can own their learning!” has been a collective rallying cry for a while now. But, if we are making it a priority and going so far as to add it to lesson planning requirements , why isn’t it translating to classroom practice or higher student outcomes? I’ve realized that giving general feedback to “increase student engagement” just isn’t good practice. Here are some feedback strategies that will get you the results you want to see.

In the past two months alone, six school leaders have told me that ‘increasing student engagement’ is a top priority. Some have even redesigned lesson planning requirements and made it a focus in collaborative planning sessions. I’m guilty of having given that advice to schools and teachers over the past several years, as well. “Let’s all work to increase student engagement so that students can own their learning!” has been a collective rallying cry for a while now. 

But, if we are making it a priority and going so far as to add it to lesson planning requirements , why isn’t it translating to classroom practice or higher student outcomes?

It’s because educators have vastly different perceptions of what student engagement actually means. It’s because student engagement is layered. No single formula works in every classroom. And honestly, planning for student engagement can seem daunting if it’s seen as “one more thing” to add to the lesson planning list. 

Teachers already know students need to be engaged. So when a leader says, ‘increase student engagement’ after an observation, it can sting. Most teachers are already trying everything they can to keep minds active and hands raised. When that effort goes unseen, the feedback can feel deflating, like no amount of trying is ever enough.

But it’s not their fault. I’ve realized that giving general feedback to “increase student engagement” just isn’t good practice. The feedback we should be giving instead is a tailored, concrete move that the teacher could use to improve instruction in the very next lesson. It should also serve as a strategy that can be replicated into other lessons with minimal preparation. 

Instead of vague directives, here are some ways to turn a broad statement into concrete, bite-sized feedback.

Try This

Example

  • Identify a quick data point to be improved.

During a lesson with 26 students, the same 5 students kept raising their hands to volunteer answers to questions. The rest of the students weren’t engaging.

  • Develop a concrete move the teacher could incorporate the very next lesson to improve that data.

“To increase the number of students answering questions, embed a 30-second ‘turn and talk’ opportunity for students to discuss the answer with a partner. Then ask the question again whole-group.”

or

“During the two most important questions of the lesson, incorporate a stop-and-jot in which students quickly jot their responses on a sticky note or whiteboard, and turn and share with a partner. This will allow you to monitor student understanding while they engage in the thinking.”

or

If only a few students are participating in a group activity, suggest something like this: “Have students jot their answer first, then whip around the table to share out. This will ensure that 100% of students are responding.”

  • Make sure the move is immediately actionable and can be easily used across multiple lessons.

The examples above can easily be transferred across lessons with minimal prep and management. 

But, if we are making it a priority and going so far as to add it to lesson planning requirements , why isn’t it translating to classroom practice or higher student outcomes?

This kind of feedback may feel too simplified when lack of student engagement is an overwhelming problem, but trust the process and watch the difference. Something exciting happens when a teacher can take a bite-sized action and see instant results in student engagement. As an added bonus, it establishes you as a partner in improving data and outcomes, not as someone giving a subjective review of their performance.

If you want teachers to increase engagement, start by increasing the clarity of your feedback. 

The impact will surprise you. Read our next blog in this series where we’ll break down more coaching moves that actually stick!

Success Criteria: 2 Questions to Make This Process Feel Less Like Rocket Science

Courtney Dumas headshot

Courtney Dumas,

CEO

October 7, 2025

There has been a sudden interest and requirement for teachers to post success criteria for lessons. These two words paired together have set the current educational world on fire, but many teachers are left wondering: what IS success criteria exactly, and why do my students need to know what it is?

Traveling the state of Louisiana and visiting many different classrooms in the past two months has taught me two things. First, teachers can make any magic happen in the classroom. Second, that magic is a whole lot easier to make when instructional guidance from leaders is clear. For instance, there has been a sudden interest and requirement for teachers to post success criteria for lessons. These two words paired together have set the current educational world on fire, but many teachers are left wondering: what IS success criteria exactly, and why do my students need to know what it is?

In a two week period, I have witnessed wildly different versions of success criteria, ranging from kindergarten through high school. In one classroom, the teacher’s success criteria created four additional objectives for a lesson. Another teacher had a list of standards scripted out as their success criteria. And yet, a third teacher’s success criteria listed skills that were aligned with standards below grade-level. It is evident that someone had made it a requirement to have success criteria posted, but the guidance had obviously not been clear enough so that teachers could hit the mark. This realization brought a single question to mind–what are the expectations of posting a lesson’s success criteria? I was surprised when many leaders I spoke to during these visits were not able to definitively answer this question, and it seemed to me we had a lot of spaghetti being thrown at the wall in hopes that something stuck!

We might have an instructional mess on our hands if we allow a variety of interpretations of a single skill to be spread from class to class. Imagine if we all interpreted stoplights differently–for some people red means “stop,” and for others, red means “go.”  This would be a disaster. Without knowing the success criteria for creating success criteria, we can find ourselves in a major traffic jam. (See what I did there?)

Defining Success Criteria

First, let’s break it down. What does this mysterious phrase, success criteria, truly mean? Starting with the word success, we can infer that this phrase has to do with the accomplishment of a goal. Hmmmm … now that is starting to sound familiar. Where do teachers begin when they are lesson planning? They start with a lesson focus (or goal if you will). An effective lesson focus is written as a goal for how the students will meet the identified grade-level standard by the end of that lesson. What about the word, criteria? This term is referencing the evaluation of a goal. We know our main goal is the lesson focus, so now we have to consider what student work would look like in order to show mastery of the identified grade-level standard or task. 



DOWNLOAD OUR SUCCESS CRITERIA FLOWCHART

The Need for Success Criteria

So, why is it necessary to include success criteria during instruction? First, success criteria help students get started with a task. By providing a clear list of student-friendly expectations, teachers remove barriers by eliminating the worry of “What does the teacher want me to say or do?”

Next, success criteria are used to measure student learning toward the standard-aligned goal of the lesson. This means that success criteria will change from lesson to lesson because what is being measured is also changing. But this doesn’t have to add fifty-seven additional steps in the lesson planning process, nor does it need to include a complicated unpacking of an entire standard. The success criteria serve as a collective tool that students use to monitor their progress. It also allows teachers to give individualized, specific, and real-time feedback that help students grow toward mastery of grade-level standards. Simply put, it is a set of expectations for students to follow when expressing their understanding. Now, let’s let’s talk about how we make creating success criteria painless.

Creating Success Criteria

During planning, you should see the development of a common through-line. When the lesson’s focus standard, objective, and check for understanding are aligned, it makes creating success criteria that much easier. 

To simplify the process, it all boils down to two questions:

  1. What knowledge do students need to successfully complete the task?
  2. What skills do students need to successfully complete the task?

That’s it! No fancy, super-complicated process is needed. For some lessons, a teacher may only need to quickly check the knowledge students have gained. For others, they may only need to check the skill acquired or practiced during the lesson. And for an occasional few, the lesson check for understanding may measure both. The knowledge and skills you identify will correlate to all parts of the lesson and make student expectations clear.

If you or a group of teachers find yourselves staring at a blank piece of anchor chart paper not knowing where to even begin, try completing the task as if you were one of your students. Put yourself in their seat and feel the task from their perspective. Ask yourself: What do students need to know in order to complete the task (knowledge)? What do students need to do in order to express their understanding (skills)? The answers to these questions will build that lesson’s success criteria.  

Taking it to the Next Level

Once teachers and students are comfortable with implementing success criteria regularly, the next level is to turn this practice over to students, so they can begin creating success criteria on their own. One way to accomplish this is by providing students with an exemplar (that doesn’t give away an answer), and have them identify what makes the exemplar successful. This can lead to peer feedback opportunities where students take ownership and grow one another’s performance toward mastery. 

Another way to make success criteria more student-led is through task analysis. When setting students up to complete a task, show them how to break apart the task into separate parts. Prompt students with some thinking questions: What is this task asking me to do? How many answers do I need to provide? What information is provided in the question? What additional information is needed? 

Success in Success Criteria

The most important thing to remember about success criteria is that it is designed to help students understand expectations and for teachers to track student progress. At the same time, it is critical to NOT overcomplicate it. Teachers should not feel like this is yet another thing to check off of their list for the sake of compliance, but instead a tool that adds value to their instruction.

Be sure to follow us on social media to get access to free resources that can add a little SPARKLE to your instruction.


Facebook


X-twitter


Instagram

Start Strong: 4 Power Moves Every Instructional Coach Needs in August/September

Courtney Dumas headshot

Courtney Dumas,

CEO

September 18, 2025

Where should instructional leaders start at the beginning of the school year? Should there be a specific structure or rhythm to begin their coaching and support? While there are no scientifically proven answers to those questions, our team has learned firsthand some instructional leadership moves that make a massive difference in learning outcomes. Here are our top four recommendations.

Any teacher will quickly tell you that the first few weeks of school always fly by in the blink of an eye. How did it get to be mid-September already?  As the year begins, there’s a cadence and rhythm that the majority of teachers expertly slide into: learn the students, cover expectations, and begin lessons with the content and curriculum. But for instructional leaders and coaches, the structures for back to school are often varied and widespread.

So, where should instructional leaders start? Should there be a specific structure or rhythm to begin their coaching and support?

While there are no scientifically proven answers to those questions, our team has learned firsthand some instructional leadership moves that make a massive difference in learning outcomes. Here are our top four recommendations:

1. Know the instructional goal(s) you’ll be working toward with teachers as early as possible.

The most effective, impactful instructional coaching happens when there is a clear target that a school, subject, or grade level is trying to reach. Is your school trying to improve reading scores? Decrease the number of students in math interventions? Whatever the goal, that should be the focus of any instructional support.

“But what if teacher evaluations haven’t been done yet, and I’m not sure what coaching is needed? I’m just waiting and building relationships with teachers before jumping in.” This is exactly what I used to think until I learned from Jill Jackson that trust is a byproduct of coaching support that gets real results. And it all starts with knowing where you’re heading–  the instructional goal. 

Once you know the big goal, it’s time to think about the people who need the most support reaching it.

2. Connect with new teachers right away.

This may seem pretty obvious to some, but if you haven’t gotten around to your new teachers yet, you’ll want to move this action item to the top of your list. It might seem counterintuitive to schedule time with new teachers at the beginning of the year for fear of overwhelming them. After all, they probably have a lot to learn and tons to do in a limited amount of time, and as coaches we can feel like we don’t want to “add one more thing” to their plate. However, the beauty of instructional coaching support is that, if done well, it can feel like relief. Who is better equipped to give teachers the right guidance for curriculum, explain what coaching will look and sound like, and how you will work as a team to reach instructional goals?

After connecting with new teachers, level up your coaching by widening your lens and noticing instructional patterns.

3. Begin gathering instructional trend data as soon as possible.

Besides knowing the school’s instructional goals, a clear understanding of what instruction looks and sounds like in classrooms is arguably one of the most important tools in an instructional leader’s toolbox. Informal classroom visits will provide critical data on where to begin your coaching cycles and teacher support.

Instructional trend data helps coaches and leaders plan their support for teachers in getting quick instructional wins. You’ll want to organize your instructional trend data into two categories: 

  • Which teachers need support in Priority Skills (Classroom Management, Student Engagement, Behavior Management, Lesson Planning, Delivery of a Basic Lesson)?

  • Which teachers are ready to jump straight into progressing toward the school’s instructional goal?

But data by itself doesn’t change instruction. The magic happens when teachers come together and reflect on that data and how they can support their students. So once you’ve gathered the trends, the next power move is turning that information into intentional planning time.

4. Begin scheduling and designing collaborative planning sessions.

One of the most critical currencies in a school is time. Because time is so limited, collaborative planning must be intentional and worth the investment. When teachers feel that planning is productive rather than “one more thing,” they lean in.

So how can leaders make that happen? By designing collaborative planning around instructional trends and school goals. Trend data can guide not only individual teacher support but also become the blueprint for planning by answering these questions:

  • What should our focus be?

  • How often do we need to meet?

  • What data are we aiming to impact?

Intentional planning early in the year means teachers can meet student needs sooner and see progress toward goals. It’s the difference between a wish and a plan because, as one author put it, ‘a goal without a plan is just a wish.’ By setting the plan in motion now, leaders turn collaborative planning into a lever for real results.

To jumpstart your own work, grab the quick planner below and jot your thoughts. It’s your first step toward leveling up teacher support.

4 Power Moves to Level Up Your Coaching at the Beginning of the Year

(Quick Planner)

Power Move

Considerations

Your Information

  1. Instructional Goals 

  • What are the school’s primary instructional goals for the year?

  1. New Teachers

  • Who are the new teachers?

  • When is the best time to meet with each one?

  1. Instructional Trends

  • What are the top classroom instructions trends? (2-3)

  • Which teachers need support in Priority Skills?

  • Which teachers are ready to work on the instructional goal?

 
  1. Collaborative Planning

  • Based on instructional trends, what is the focus for collaborative planning sessions?

  • How frequently do teachers need to meet?